Sona Mohapatra Questions Whether Silence Equals Respect in Daler Mehndi Controversy

Singer Sona Mohapatra has weighed in on the controversy surrounding Daler Mehndi's performance in Uttarakhand, raising a pointed question about professional accountability in the performing arts and arguing that audiences deserve respect too.

In a long note posted on Instagram, Sona recalled headlining the first evening of a Sufi festival in Delhi in February, with Daler Mehndi booked as the closing act the following evening on March 1. She said she and her team stayed back an extra night because they were excited to watch the veteran singer perform what they had been told would be a Sufi-oriented set.

"Artists rarely stay back after their own shows. We are usually on the next flight out," she wrote, adding that the organisers kindly accommodated their request to stay another night. "We were genuinely excited to watch a legend perform what we had been told would be a very different, Sufi-oriented set."

What followed, she said, was heartbreaking. "From where we watched, Daler ji appeared disoriented, struggled to hold a note and kept repeating the same musical phrase."

The "Bedardi Raja" singer also expressed disappointment with the overall production, recalling how audience members gradually began leaving the venue. "We watched audience members gradually leave, people who had paid good money and come with great expectations," she wrote, adding that she felt for the organisers who had invested their resources and reputations into presenting a respected artist.

She then turned to the silence that followed. "None of us said anything. Not my team, not me. We stood there, uncomfortable and saddened, but silent. Out of respect. Which brings me to the uncomfortable part. Was that really respect? Or were we, through our silence, enabling something that deserved to be questioned?"

Sona made clear she had no knowledge of Daler Mehndi's personal circumstances or health and would not presume to diagnose what she witnessed. She also said publicly humiliating an artist is no solution. But she found it curious that so much of the conversation around the Uttarakhand controversy had centred on the indignity suffered by the artist and so little on the expectations of the audience and the responsibility of those accepting substantial professional fees.

"Two things can be true," she wrote. "A veteran deserves dignity, empathy and gratitude for a lifetime of contribution. And an audience deserves an honest performance, or at the very least, an honest acknowledgement when that is no longer possible."

She argued that if someone is unwell, there must be compassion and a responsible way to handle the situation, but that it cannot become acceptable for audiences and organisers to repeatedly bear the consequences while everyone around the artist looks away. On the Uttarakhand minister's handling of the situation, she said that was a separate question, but asked whether the manner of his objection automatically invalidates the substance of the complaint.

"I ask this as a fellow performing artist, fully aware that I may be criticised for saying it," she wrote. "Respect is not a one-way entitlement. It is a relationship of reciprocity. Age, legacy and stature deserve reverence. They do not exempt any of us from professional accountability."

She closed by saying those who remained silent that evening, herself included, need to ask whether their well-intentioned deference helped anyone at all. "I share this with sadness, not malice. And with genuine respect for the extraordinary legacy of Daler Mehndi ji. But surely, we owe our audiences some respect too?"

Advertisement